- Title: Somme
- Author: Lyn Macdonald
- ISBN: 9780140178678
- Page: 286
- Format: Paperback
This book looks at the Battle of the Somme, which was planned as The Big Push that would at last break the long stalemate on the Western Front in World War I However the 18 divisions that went over the top between Arras and St Quentin on the morning of 1 July 1916, walked into a battle that has gone down in the annals of human conflict as the slaughterhouse of a generatioThis book looks at the Battle of the Somme, which was planned as The Big Push that would at last break the long stalemate on the Western Front in World War I However the 18 divisions that went over the top between Arras and St Quentin on the morning of 1 July 1916, walked into a battle that has gone down in the annals of human conflict as the slaughterhouse of a generation The author has written other books about the history of World War I, including, They Called it Passchendaele and The Roses of No Man s Land.
Recent Comments "Somme"
This book ranged from 2 to 5 Stars for me. Two stars because I expected a history of the Somme battle. This is not a history of the Somme campaign, it is a haphazard account of days, conditions, participants, events large and small over a period from July 1, 2016 to November 2016. While roughly chronological, you will get an idea of what happened but I wanted a true battle history.The book gets five stars for what she brings to you, accounts mostly in the original words of the soldiers who fough [...]
When I first read Lyn MacDonald a decade ago, I was less than impressed with her. The book seemed to be a disjointed series of first-hand accounts with very little added in her own hand.That observation still prohibits a 5-star rating, alltough Peter Hart outdoes MacDonald in undercementing his tape transcripts, but provided you have a little knowledge about the campaign at hand, these pages breathe new life into the names set in the cold tombstones of the CWGC. With the last Victorian generatio [...]
As an amatuer military historian I spent years ignoring World War One. In retrospect that was foolish on my part. But like many others I had the war pegged to a few cliches and sterotypes and didn't feel the need to investigate any further. In the fall of 1999 I had a few months left in the U.S. Army. I was preparing to go into the field to assist on a field problem. I knew that there would be long hours of radio watches and manning gates. I found a copy ofThe Sommein the post (base for those wh [...]
A lengthy, chilling history of the Battle of the Somme, told mainly through the eyes of British officers, NCOs, and soldiers, many of them interviewed by MacDonald herself. As the author puts it. the book is more about “the experience of war” than any “political conclusions.” As such, the book is heavy on such topics as life in the trenches and the experience of battle, and MacDonald tells this story with compassion, and does a fine job bringing to life the era (“those days before inst [...]
This is an excellent book covering the Battle of Somme in 1916. The one drawback, as with all of Macdonald's work, is that the book only deals with the role of the UK and Commonwealth countries in the Battle. The book is very readable, with excellent maps, and a good description of the horrors of the battle(s). I liked the eyewitness accounts of various aspects of the battles, life in the trenches, training camps, visiting home an leave, life back in the UK, etc. I really also enjoyed he multipl [...]
Wat de boeken van Lyn Macdonald over de Eerste Wereldoorlog zo prettig maakt, is dat ze precies de goed mix hebben tussen feitelijke weergave van de gebeurtenissen en ooggetuigenverslagen. De slag bij de Somme was een hel, een gevolg van verkeerde inschattingen, koppigheid van de generale staf van de Britten en onbegrijpelijke opofferingsgezindheid. Macdonald schrijft met distantie en neemt een objectief standpunt in. Ze geeft ons de waarnemingen door, zonder hinderlijk oordeel. Wij mogen als le [...]
The more I read about WW1 the more I am fascinated by it. History is stranger than fiction, nobody could make this up.The british Somme offensive in 1916 was one of the most attritious battles of WW1. Lyn Macrdonald brings it vividly to life with very readable prose interlaced with hundreds of personal accounts of the combatants. The amount of research which has gone into this book is mind staggering.The other books of Lyn Macdonald about WW1 are already ordered, cant wait.
This is one of the earliest books I can remember borrowing from the local library. I read it more than once, or at least tried to.I've always had an uneasy fascination with war and what soldiers endured in battle conditions.Reading the personal encounters of soldiers who fought and died in this major military blunder is very poignant. Little would they know that their scribbled notes to wives and sweethearts would be preserved for all to read.
I've given this book three stars as a reflection of my personal difficulties in reading this. If I was trying to be objective, 4 stars would be fairer.Although I am interested in histories of both the World Wars I am not interested in military history. You can immediately see the obvious contradiction. So, for example, Lyn Macdonald's The Roses of No Man's Land was ideal for me, containing rich descriptions of the impact of war. Clearly, any book about an actual battle is going to be structured [...]
Superb. I don't normally read history books because I find them dry and boring. This one was different - the prose was relaxed and read more like a non-fiction book. The accounts from soldiers who actually fought were interspersed throughout the text. The book also focused on areas of a soldier's life other than fighting. The account wasn't sensational, but told the story of the battles in a sympathetic way. Highly recommended.
Another excellent book by Lyn. As good as any of her other WWI books, whatever she writes about, she is top notch at descriptive essential to understanding, while bringing such cataclysmic events down to an individual level required for empathy. Sublime writing, simply put.
The accounts from the soldiers who were there are fascinating.
Few battles are as seared into the British historical consciousness as the battle of the Somme, the months-long offensive against the German trenches during the First World War. There the newly-trained divisions of "Kitchener's Army" suffered hundreds of thousands of casualties, all for advances that were often measured in yards. It was a baptism of blood, one that often depopulated villages back home of an entire generation of young men and left an indelible impression on the minds of its survi [...]
In the summer of the second year of the Great War, British and French troops mounted an offensive against the Hun along the Somme River in northern France. The Germans had been entrenched for the previous two years and were solidly fortified. Charge after charge by mostly British troops (many of the French were redirected to fighting at Verdun) amounted to no more than a few hundred yards of real estate after the first two months. With the remnants of practically an entire generation of Great Br [...]
It seems wrong to say that I enjoyed this book given it's subject matter, but the enjoyment comes from the enlightenment - this is an educational read but the author manages to mix personal testimony, fine detail and overall perspective so well that this felt far removed from a dry historical read. (It also helped that this book was the present my son brought back for me from a school WWI Battlefields tour, what better present for a book lover?)A further strength of the book, for me, was that th [...]
What can you say about a book that looks at hell? The author does a superb job looking not only at the first day but the whole campaign.
Lyn Macdonald's books on the British army in the First World War seek not to offer a military history, not a complete one anyway, but to portray one facet of it, that of the experiences of the ordinary men in the front line. In that, Somme is quite successful. And, to the extent that it does offer comment on the direction of the battle by senior officers, the book is refreshingly free of the 'Lions led by donkeys' rhetoric. But this is only a facet of the military campaign fought by the British [...]
The last of four Macdonald books I picked up in a charity shop. Like the others, They Called It Passchendaele, The Roses of No Man's Land and 1915 The Death Of Innocence, 'Somme' combines the big picture with the personal experiences of those involved, skilfully weaving sometimes harrowing, sometimes hilarious first person accounts into the narrative. The work is from the '80s, but is dated only by a throwaway remark in the introduction about writers seldom being able to afford a personal comput [...]
Of all the military history books I've read, this is probably my least favourite. I was not a fan of the writing. While the information included was good, thorough, and interesting, I had hoped for more information on Beaumont Hamel and the Newfoundlanders. This book, however, is about Kitchener's Army. The last few paragraphs of the book were my favourite and definitely sum up the book in a few words. "They were, in short, fifteen soldiers of Kitchener's Army."
2016 Modern Mrs. Darcy Reading Challenge: A book that intimidates you. I read this on the 100th anniversary of the Battle of the Somme. Finally got around to reading this after, oh, 25 years. I had previously read several of Macdonald's books and found them difficult because of the waste of human life that was discussed. Came back to this now that I'm older and wiser. Incredible carnage, what a waste.
The Somme was a long, bloody, affair. Perhaps for that reason, Lyn MacDonald's account of this epic battle lacks, for this reader, some of the coherence of her other works. However, as ever, her skill is in pulling together the accounts of the men who fought, bled and, sometimes, died. Their words bring to life this hell on earth that lasted over four costly months. If not her best book, still entirely readable.
to hear the voices of the men, who fought during the wr remember me of the tale of my mother's side greathmother born in Triest and of her memories. The only fault in her books are that English men died everywhere. I remember the burial cemetery of Magnaboschi on Asiago's plateu, where the brother of Vera Brittain feel. Apart Gallipoli the war remin concerned on the landres.
Tragic account of a Great War battle in which the first tanks were introduced. The story uses the perspective of a front line soldier effectively and includes many first hand accounts for that purpose. However, it would be wise to be familiar with the strategy and tactics to better understand the story line.
This book so far is very good . She explains well , using her words to paint a picture , making it come alive for the reader . She has used the soldiers own experiences throughout the book , some of them very moving and graphic . All in all if you are interested in The First World War and the soldiers experiences you cant go far wrong in buying this book or any of the others by Lyn MacDonald !
an excellent read, featuring a lot of eyewitness accounts, all of them no longer with us one of the most striking things about this book with its reliance on personal accounts is the apparent void in the narrative when it comes to the first morning of the Battle of the Somme, but then most of those tommies with the more compelling stories never left the field of battle that day
For an very dense and accurate account of one of the worlds most horrific offenses, it is a surprisingly easy read. Staggering in its account of mans meat grinder mentality to the words "casualty" and "collateral damage". This book disturbed me Pointless massacring on this scale should never be forgotten.
A good account. There seemed to be some unexplored aspects of the story. For example the reaction at home could have been expanded upon. Many personal narratives. I'm not sure how the soldiers did it, going over the top time and again into machine gun fire and artillery. Madness!
Detailed account of British army attacks on the Somme in 1916, given depth by eye-witness testimonies of survivors. Very moving as a result. I would have preferred more maps to make it easier to understand the smaller scale events.
the more I read about the common soldier's experience in WWI, the more depressing and wasteful it all seemedjust frightful wasting of lives
Easy to read history of the Somme battle but not written for military historians. Extensive diary entries to document the life lived in this time.
✓ Somme || ✓ PDF Read by ✓ Lyn Macdonald 286 Lyn Macdonald
Title: ✓ Somme || ✓ PDF Read by ✓ Lyn Macdonald